This is default featured slide 1 title

Go to Blogger edit html and find these sentences.Now replace these sentences with your own descriptions.

This is default featured slide 2 title

Go to Blogger edit html and find these sentences.Now replace these sentences with your own descriptions.

This is default featured slide 3 title

Go to Blogger edit html and find these sentences.Now replace these sentences with your own descriptions.

This is default featured slide 4 title

Go to Blogger edit html and find these sentences.Now replace these sentences with your own descriptions.

This is default featured slide 5 title

Go to Blogger edit html and find these sentences.Now replace these sentences with your own descriptions.

Showing posts with label Sports. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sports. Show all posts

Saturday, December 21, 2013

Should Bonds, McGwire and Clemens be in the Hall? Yes.

I was on Google+, and the question was raised, "Who should get in to the Hall of Fame?" I said that players like Bonds, Clemens and McGwire should go in. A commenter named Chris Pratt (not the actor) had this to say:
Steroids were illegal in every other professional sport at the time and against the law to sell or possess.
There is no way Bonds did what he did without steroids. That's why you keep them all out.
I'm a native of St. Louis and was at the game where McGwire hit 62 and 70. Those were two games I will never forget, but they are tarnished because of the fact that they wouldn't have happened without the roids.
None of them deserve to go into the hall.
These are common points, and we'll go through each one of them, one-by-one.


"Steroids were illegal in every other professional sport at the time and against the law to sell or possess."

Here's something crazy: The NBA didn't test for marijuana for years. In recent years, they've started doing tests, but as recently as 1997, there was no testing in place. All the other major sports leagues had it in place, and it was, of course, illegal in the US to sell or possess.

So, if an NBA player was found to be using marijuana during that time, should they not be allowed in the Hall?

You could say, "Marijuana isn't a performance-enhancing substance! It's used for relaxation and recreation!" However, if a player has a PED in his system, we don't care what they used it for. It's banned, right?

Let's use an example of something that is, in fact, a performance enhancing drug. Baseball allowed amphetamines up until about 2006. Some say that it's more responsible for the drop in power than steroid use. However, amphetamines were illegal in other sports and illegal to sell or buy.

So, should all players that used amphetamines be kicked out ot the Hall? If you do that, get ready to kick out Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, and practically every great player you know.

Putting it all together: If we're going to base our opinion of steroids in baseball on what other leagues allowed or disallowed, we're going to go down a weird path that includes a lot of doublespeak and weird contradictions.

"There is no way Bonds did what he did without steroids."

Does Barry Bonds hit 72 home runs in 2001 without steroids? It's highly unlikely. However, as the story goes, Bonds saw the adulation that was thrown at McGwire when he broke the home run record. Bonds always felt underappreciated for his skills, so he decided to take steroids starting in 2000 in order to beef his home run totals.

The estimable Jonah Keri compiled Bonds' stats up until 2000, and came up with this career:
2,000 games played
445 home runs
1,299 RBIs
1,455 runs scored
460 stolen bases
.288/.409/.559
3 MVPs
102.5 WAR
Here are his money quotes:
"The next-highest WAR during that 1986-99 stretch belongs to Ken Griffey Jr., at 68.5."
"Bonds's first 14 years work out to the sum of Jimmie Foxx's entire career. And of course, this exercise twistedly assumes that without PEDs, Bonds would've been eaten by wolves on Christmas Day 1999 and never played again."
He also looks at another player of the era, Roger Clemens:
"Just for fun, let's try the same exercise with Clemens, counting everything up to the Rocket's otherworldly numbers in Toronto:
2,776 innings pitched
2,590 strikeouts
3.06 ERA
83.4 WAR
The next-highest WAR during that 1984-96 stretch belongs to Greg Maddux, at 58.5. Clemens's first 13 years top Warren Spahn's entire career."
I think those numbers speak for themselves. These are players who would have been great with or without steroids.

However, the next quote really sums up what's really bothering the voters and the fans.

"I'm a native of St. Louis and was at the game where McGwire hit 62 and 70. Those were two games I will never forget, but they are tarnished because of the fact that they wouldn't have happened without the roids."

I'll always argue that there were three events that brought baseball all the way back from the 1994 strike: Cal Ripken breaking Lou Gehrig's consecutive games record, the Sosa/McGwire home run chase, and the 2004 Red Sox/Yankees series. You may have your own choices, but I think we can all agree that these were some pretty big events.

Knowing what we know now about the so-called Steroid Era, it seems silly that the home run chase had such a huge effect, but it was all anyone could talk about in 1998. McGwire and Sosa seemed to be good guys, they were having fun, we were having fun and no one seemed to care.

At the time, though, there were journalists who were poking around McGwire and brought to light his use of andro. We all knew that he was taking, but no one said anything or seemed to care. It was just swept under the rug.

When we talk about how we feel "hurt" or "betrayed" by the players that hit all those home runs, it's a little odd. We knew that players were taking things. We didn't care at the time. We wanted them to do it. It would be like a boyfriend encouraging his girlfriend to cheat on him, then having people tell him that she's cheating and he does nothing about it and ignores it. Then, years later, he decides to throw that back in her face and break up with her.

We, the fans, saw players using substances and did nothing. Look at McGwire as a rookie:


And McGwire years later:


Only those with their head in the sand refused to believe he was on something. We knew about steroids, and we knew they were in McGwire's locker. We didn't care.

Now, years later, we're going to hold players like Bonds, McGwire and Clemens responsible for what we as fans allowed them to do with impunity? That's unfair.

"None of them deserve to go into the hall."

So then who does? Only players like Maddux who are skinny and don't look like they took steroids? Is a player's build a guarantee that they never took anything? The first person suspended for steroids was Alex Sanchez. He was 5'10" and 180 pounds soaking wet.

Steroids also help a player come back from injury faster. Maddux was pretty durable. Is the fact that he wasn't injured a lot a sign that he was taking steroids?

I'm not saying anything against Maddux, mind you. For the record, I believe he was clean. I'm just making a point: If you start suspecting everyone of steroids and lumping them all together, some weird mental arithmetic starts to happen. You start believing players are clean because you believe they're clean, and that some players are dirty because they're dirty.

You simply can't do that. When deciding who goes into the Hall, you have to stack players up against players of their own era, apples to apples. If a player is head and shoulders above players of their own era, they should go into the Hall. That's what the Hall is: A place where the best players of their era are enshrined. You can try and make the argument that a Hall of Fame is some sort of moral museum, but that argument falls apart when you look at the fact that Ty Cobb, one of the game's worst people, is in the Hall, as well as Kennesaw Mountain Landis, a virulent racist who fought to keep the leagues segregated.

The truth is, we want to keep players out of the Hall because we're mad. That's it. We're just angry. But, frankly, it's our own fault, not the fault of the players for doing what we wanted them to. For that reason, we have to get over it and let the best players of the era into the Hall.

Sources:

http://www.nytimes.com/1997/10/26/sports/marijuana-and-pro-basketball-a-special-report-nba-s-uncontrolled-substance.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm
http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/baseball/baseball-experts-amphetamines-ban-steroids-biggest-reason-steep-drop-offense-article-1.182105
http://www.grantland.com/story/_/id/10155321/breaking-baseball-hall-fame-ballot

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Baseball Player Ryan Freel Had CTE: Why Aren't We Freaking Out?

Ryan Freel was a utility player, bouncing around the major leagues for about eight seasons. During his career, he took a few shots to the head and had problems with memory loss and headaches. He finally retired in 2010 after he couldn't shake the injuries caused by a pickoff throw to the head in 2009.

Ryan Freel committed suicide in 2012. The family had his brain investigated, and found that Ryan Freel had evidence of CTE (chronic traumatic encephalopathy) in his brain. CTE, if you'll recall, is the disease that destroys boxers and has ravaged the NFL. It's a degenerative disease that appears to be caused by repeated head injuries.

This is the first case of a baseball player being diagnosed with CTE. So why aren't we freaking out like we do with boxing and football?

More and more, it's appearing that there is nothing that can be done to make football "safe." For example, Rob Gronkowski of the New England Patriots got injured a few weeks ago. The defensive player went low to avoid hitting Gronkowski in the head, and ended up destroying Gronkowski's ACL in the process. However, Gronkowski still suffered a concussion on the play, rendering the defensive player's attempt to protect Gronkowski's head meaningless and destroying his knee and career for nothing.

During a game, there are only three people on the field that are not guaranteed to have contact with another player: The quarterback, the kicker and the punter. Most of the time, even those three players are not immune. Every other player is bound to have contact in some form or another, whether it's blocking or tackling. Contact is part of the game. Remove contact from football and you're just playing tag.

It doesn't matter how you legislate football. The game is always going to be about collisions and hitting, which has been proven to cause brain trauma and eventually brain damage. You can try and prevent players from hitting high, give them extra padding in their helmets and flag players for rough hits, but the result is the same: People will get hurt, and seriously so.

Likewise, how would you remove head injuries from boxing? Remove knockouts? Disallow punches to the head? If you make changes like those, then it's no longer boxing.

Baseball, however, is not a contact sport. Yes, Freel sustained injuries while playing, but those were, for lack of a better term, accidents. For example, a baseball player shouldn't normally get hit in the head on a pickoff throw. When you play baseball as it's meant to be played, concussions and head trauma do not happen.

Baseball has also made efforts to curb the contact, like removing collisions at the plate. (Side note for those who think the rule change is a sign of the further wussification of America: Why was it that the catcher could block the plate but no one else? If blocking the bases were allowed for everyone, Prince Fielder's value would skyrocket.) A player still might fling themselves into a wall or get hit on the head, but our ongoing understanding of head trauma is going to make sure that players keep themselves safe.

Now, do head injuries happen in baseball? Absolutely. Head injuries can also happen if you're working construction, or working as a welder. Head injuries are an abnormal part of the job, not a normal part.

Freel's case, while tragic, is an outlier in the sport. In the last ten years, we've learned so much more about head injuries, which should help keep players safe in the future. The key takeaway, though, is this: Unlike football, baseball can and will be made safer. Hopefully, the sad case of Ryan Freel will spur the process along.

Friday, August 2, 2013

Ryan Braun, Baseball, and MLB's Problem

So, Ryan Braun was suspended for... something. Something bad. The evidence hasn't been released, but baseball assures us it was bad.

The story is that they gave Braun two choices: Take a longer suspension with a possibility of appealing it, or accept the shorter suspension with no appeal. Most everyone assumes that Braun was presented with hefty evidence that he was guilty, so he took the shorter suspension with no appeal.

What's absolutely amazing is that everyone is clearly accepting the league's story on this. The whole way through the Biogenesis investigation, baseball has bullied players and leaked information to the media. For example, suspensions haven't even been announced yet, and we already know that Jhonny Peralta of the Tigers will probably be suspended and A-Rod will probably be suspended, either for life or a year.

How do we know that information? The league leaked it. Why would they leak this information? Because that way the narrative starts, and it's a narrative that's favorable to the league office. "Baseball is keeping cheaters out! They're keeping the game clean! 'A-Roid' and Braun are part of the problem!"

Baseball, however, is guilty of something else: Overcorrection and a lack of transparency.

MLB usually overcorrects. For example, after the Black Sox scandal, baseball cracked down on gambling. Pete Rose paid the price. By all accounts, Rose should be in the Hall. He's one of the best players of his generation. Shoeless Joe Jackson was more than likely innocent of his involvement in the Black Sox scandal. He should be in the Hall too. Yet, neither of these players will ever, ever be in the Hall because baseball overcorrected.

Baseball is overcorrecting on PED use as well. Yes, McGwire took PEDs. Yes, Bonds and Clemens took PEDs. There were a lot of players who did, but the best players still outperformed the lower players. Singling out McGwire, Sosa, Bonds and Clemens isn't fair. They deserve to be in the Hall. Bonds and Clemens deserved it on the first ballot. They were positively among the best players of their generation.

Because MLB was fooled once on PED use, they're determined not to get fooled again. That's why they're hammering Alex Rodriguez as hard as they can, and that's why they suspended Braun. It's an overcorrection.

The problem with Braun: He doesn't have a positive test they can point to. A lot of people feel that Braun got off on a technicality last time around, but there's a reason that there's a chain of custody for drug tests. If you get a positive drug test and the chain of custody is shown to be broken, that test is thrown out from a practical and legal standpoint. If the chain of custody is broken, the test isn't valid.

Yet, who leaked the information about the positive test to the media? The league offices.

Remember, if the league office wouldn't have leaked the information, the test and the subsequent appeal would have gone unnoticed by the public. Yet, baseball leaked it, and then found themselves with egg on their face when the test methodology had problems.

Why would the league go through all that trouble? Because they want people to know they're "doing something" about PED use. Whether or not it's right, they want to be seen as doing something.

So, now we're seeing baseball cracking down again on players who were associated with the Biogenesis clinic. They got the clinic's owner to "cooperate" with the league in exchange for not suing him into oblivion. They have evidence on players, but they're not releasing that evidence. There are, to our knowledge, no positive tests. All the information that we have has been leaked by the league office.

What if this were a court case? Let's say that the prosecution leaked important details about the trial to the press, thus tainting the jury pool. Then, they don't allow the case to be a matter of public record, they don't release the evidence, they get someone who'll testify against the plaintiff or else, and to top it all off the judge and the prosecution are working together.

Would anyone consider that a fair court case? Not at all. That's a kangaroo court.

That's precisely what we're seeing now. A-Rod, Braun, Peralta and others are being tried in MLB's kangaroo court, which brands players as cheaters and tosses them in front of an angry crowd who's all too willing to tear the players apart. Does that sound fair to you?

There's another problem: During the "Steroid Era", certain players were viewed as being clean without a doubt. For example, Ken Griffey Jr. Yet, think of Griffey's career: Great young player, injury problems, then all of a sudden starts putting together consistent seasons and playing great ball at an older age. If we weren't talking about Griffey, one of the most revered players of his time, suspicion wouldn't be unreasonable.

What about Chris Davis of the Orioles? He's hit 39 home runs, and we're barely past the halfway point of the season. Is he above suspicion? He's never hit this many home runs before.

What about Bryce Harper? Mike Trout? Yasiel Puig? Any number of young players who have burst onto the scene in recent years?

Baseball's got a problem, and it has nothing to do with PEDs. It's all their doing. By their overzealousness in tracking down PED users, they act as if every player is suspect, reducing rather than reinforcing confidence in their sport. They make young, marketable players kryptonite to advertisers, as the advertisers are afraid that their investment will turn sour.

Will baseball lay off PEDs anytime soon? Not a chance. They have to protect the "integrity of the game." Well, guess what? In order to preserve something's integrity, it has to exist. If the league isn't careful, they'll destroy their sport in order to save it.

Thursday, May 3, 2012

Junior Seau and the End of the NFL As We Know It

Junior Seau, former 10-time All Pro linebacker for the San Diego Chargers, died yesterday of a gunshot wound to the chest. Police are investigating it as a suicide.

We don't have enough information to determine if this was similar to the death of Dave Duerson, the former All-Pro safety who shot himself in the chest so that science could examine his brain for CTE, but the similarities are, at least on the surface, a little eerie. After all, most people who commit suicide try and shoot themselves in the head. The chest is an odd target, especially with a pistol.

What will we find when Seau’s autopsy is made public? Will we find evidence of CTE, the same as with Duerson? Either way, the toll that the NFL takes on its players is getting to the point where it simply cannot be ignored.

This reminds me of pro wrestling, in a way. Remember recently when Chris Benoit, a guy who everyone said was a class act and model citizen, suddenly murdered his family and committed suicide? When they did an autopsy, they found the brain of an 80-year-old. I mean, take a look at this page and see how many pro wrestlers died at a young age and of what: Heart attack, drug overdose, suicide, heart attack, drug overdose, and on and on.

The thing is that football is supposed to be more professional than pro wrestling. It's supposed to be somehow more sophisticated and balletic, even though deep down we know it isn't. We know that these are seriously strong men who are colliding into each other at full force with the intent to "pop" or "send a message" to the ball carrier.

Yet, at the same time, we want to kid ourselves that the game can somehow be made "safer." Roger Goodell will hand out suspensions for bounty programs and fines for "bad apples" like James Harrison and we'll keep trying to tell ourselves that concussion awareness, better training and an improved focus on player safety can fix these problems for good.

However, looking around at the game as it stands, can you see it lasting for much longer?

Think of it like this: Let's say that from here on out, all new players are totally safe from concussions and CTE. Wonderful!

However, what about players who played in the 60's? 70's? 80's? 90's? 00's? They're still around, and they're going to have problems for the rest of their lives. Even if all current players are safe, we’re still going to be hearing about concussions and concussion-related symptoms for at least the next twenty to thirty years, if not longer.

There are some cases where baseball, basketball or soccer players die young. Ken Caminiti died at 42, Len Bias died at 21 and Fabrice Muamba very nearly died on the pitch a few months ago. However, Caminiti was an admitted steroid user, Bias took cocaine, and Muamba had an unknown heart condition. There are extenuating circumstances in these instances. By and large, players who finish up their careers in other sports go on to have long lives with their wits intact. Former baseball and basketball players have their wits about them enough that they can own teams and run them successfully. Are there any football players who played in the trenches that can say the same?

So the question becomes: Are parents going to want to let their children play a game where some of its notable stars have their lives destroyed afterwards? Why would you play a game where you have no future after you're done playing, especially when there's so much more money to be made in baseball, basketball and soccer?

It doesn’t matter what football does at this point. It doesn’t matter if they wrap the players in bubble wrap, put bumpers on the sidelines and cover the field in down pillows. It doesn’t matter if they change to one-hand touch or outlaw any form of contact other than hearty handshakes. The damage has already been done.

I don’t agree with Gregg Easterbrook, writer of Tuesday Morning Quarterback, on much anymore. However, I will agree with him on this point: There is no axiom that states that football must remain popular, and sadly, I think we're looking at the last ten great years of football. The pipeline will be empty of great players, and people will move to different sports.

I certainly don’t feel comfortable watching it anymore myself. It’s kind of like watching dogfighting: The dogs have implicit trust in their owners to treat them right, and the owners abuse that trust by putting them in dangerous situations. Football players for years have been misled about the extent of damage that the game can cause, and players such as Jamal Anderson and Don Majkowski are suing the NFL over it.

Consider the case of Jamal Anderson. In 1998 he carried the ball for a then-record 410 times and caught 27 passes during the regular season. I want you to add it up: At least 437 times in a span of 17 weeks he was hit hard in an attempt to bring him down, and then another 80 times during the playoffs. That’s not counting broken tackles, blitz pickups, or any other contact he may have sustained. If Anderson only broke 5 tackles a game (which is an underestimation) and picked up the blitz once per game (also an underestimation), it’s not inconceivable that Anderson was hit 631 times, give or take, within a span of five months of his life. That’s not including practices.

Yet Anderson kept playing. Why? Because he didn’t want to let his teammates down, didn’t want to let the fans down and didn’t want to let his coaches down. At no point did anyone step in and say, “Look, Jamal is great, but we’re hurting him. He needs to rest this week. If he wants to play, let’s make sure he’s aware of the risks before he plays.”

“That’s absurd,” you may say. “He’s a football player. That’s how they play. It’s what they do. They leave it all on the field.”

It’s true, every player knows that football destroys your body. They’re glad to do it. It’s a sport of glory and honor, where your teammates are your brothers and your family. You’re war buddies, getting injured together, getting into scrapes together, and doing everything you can to win the battle. Every player knows the toll that the sport will take on your knees, hips, shoulders, and back. They know that it cripples the players that play it, but they expect that after it’s all over they can move on and use the one part of their body that hasn’t been damaged: Their brain.

As far back as 1994, the NFL was conducting research into the problems with concussions. At the time, they said that there were no problems. All was copacetic, concussions had no long-term effects, and players could keep on bashing their brains in against other players with no consequences. The science was found to be faulty and the doctors discredited. Yet, the NFL did nothing. They didn’t warn players of the danger and pooh-poohed the risks to coaches and the media.

Now we turn to the case of Junior Seau. Over 19 years, he notched 1,849 tackles, or a little under 100 per year. However, on every single play, a defensive player either hits or gets hit, sometimes repeatedly. On every snap of the ball, he gave his all as he pummeled his opponent, and some of those hits landed on his head. He didn’t complain, he just kept hitting. After all, why would he stop? If he stopped, the ballcarrier would get away. He trusted that this coaches, teammates and the league itself would look out for his best interests.

A year after his playing career was finished, Seau, a man who by most accounts was a decent man, well-liked, honest and humble, was arrested for domestic violence, then ran his car off a cliff. Then, two years later, he shot himself in the chest, finally ending his life. Someone should have looked out for his mind while he was sacrificing his body for the sport. No one did.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Football and Sample Size

Football is starting to grate on my nerves for a few reasons. The ongoing concussion problems and the way it destroys player's bodies is one of them, but another has to do with one of the fundamentals of football itself: Sample size.

In statistical studies, results can be skewed by selecting a sample size that's too small. Let's use Skittles as an example.
In a typical bag of Skittles, there are five flavors: Strawberry, orange, lemon, lime and grape. They are in equal proportion to each other when they're made.

If I grab five Skittles at random, will I have five Skittles each of a different color? Maybe not. I might have two grape, one strawberry, one lime and one lemon. I might have three orange, one grape and one lemon. I might have four lime and one strawberry.

In this case, bad statistical analysis would be to take that miniscule sample size and conclude that the entire batch of Skittles is skewed in that direction. It would be to say, "I only have four lime and one strawberry in this group of five. That means that 80% of all Skittles are lime, 20% are strawberry, and there are no other flavors in this bag."
In football, there are only 16 games played during the year. Is that enough time to determine which are the best teams? How much statistical variance is there that we're not seeing?

We can't really figure that out using football itself. From year to year, the teams change so much that trying to extrapolate long-term data using several seasons worth of games would be absolutely ridiculous and pointless. However, we could try figuring this out using another sport: Baseball.

Every Major League Baseball team plays 162 games per year, which means that statistical anomalies are shaken out by the end of the year. A team that has a strong start with weak personnel will fade down the stretch, and a team that has a weak start but a strong team will come on toward the end.

But what happens when we shorten the season to 16 games, like football has?

First, click here to see 2011's final standings. We remember how the season shook out: The Cardinals and the Rangers met in the postseason and the Cardinals won. However, if we shorten the season to just 16 games, the same as football does, what sort of records do we have?

Since teams play at different times, we rolled back the clock to April 18th, 2011 to see what each team's record was, then adjusted the date to make sure we got the proper amount of games for each team. If the date was adjusted, we noted the adjusted date next to the team name. We are not adjusting the standings by division tiebreakers, just by percentage.

American League

EAST

NY Yankees (4/20) 10-6 .625
Toronto 7-9 .438
Tampa Bay 7-9 .438
Baltimore (4/19) 7-9 .438
Boston (4/19) 5-11 .313

CENTRAL

Cleveland 12-4 .750
Kansas City 10-6 .625
Detroit (4/17) 7-9 .438
Chicago Sox 7-9 .438
Minnesota 6-10 .375

WEST
Texas 11-5 .688
LA Angels 10-6 .625
Oakland 8-8 .500
Seattle (4/17) 5-11 .313
National League
EAST
Philadelphia (4/19) 10-6 .625
Florida (4/20) 10-6 .625
Washington (4/20)* 8-8 .533
Atlanta (4/17) 7-9 .438
NY Mets 5-11 .313

CENTRAL
Cincinnati 9-7 .563
Milwaukee 8-8 .500
Chicago Cubs 8-8 .500
Pittsburgh 8-8 .500
St. Louis 8-8 .500
Houston 5-11 .313

WEST
Colorado 12-4 .750
San Francisco 9-7 .563
Arizona 8-8 .500
LA Dodgers 7-9 .438
San Diego 7-9 .438
* Doubleheader played on 4/20.

According to the 16-game standings, four teams would be tied for the worst record in the league: Boston, Seattle, the Mets and Houston. The actual lowest records, in descending order, were Baltimore, Seattle, Minnesota and Houston.

According to the 16-game standings, there would be three teams with the highest records in the league: Cleveland, Colorado and Texas with five other teams tied at a 10-6 record (Yankees, Kansas City, Anaheim, Philadelpha and Florida). The actual top four teams with the highest records, in descending order, were Philadelphia, the Yankees, Texas and Milwaukee.

By using the 16-game schedule, your division champions in the AL would be the Yankees, Cleveland and Texas with the Royals and Angels battling it out for the wild card. The NL would be Philadelpha, Cincinnati and Colorado with Florida getting the Wild Card.

The real division champions? The Yankees, Detroit and Texas with Tampa getting the wild card in the AL, and Philadelphia, Milwaukee and Arizona with St. Louis in the wild card in the NL.

So, is the 2011 16-game schedule way, way off? There is quite a bit of variance. While a few of the really good teams would still be good under this drastically shorted schedule, over half of the true playoff teams would have been excluded under the 16-game schedule.

How significant is the variance? On average, in 2011, a 16-game schedule would have produced a variance of 93.56 percentage points. That's an entire win and a half in football terms. That may not sound like much, but one or two wins would have changed the entire playoff picture. The eventual Super Bowl winners, the Giants, may have missed the playoffs altogether. The Broncos may not have made the playoffs, the Titans may have, the Cowboys, Eagles, Bears or Cardinals may have made it while the Falcons and Lions may not have, and so on.

But we don't want to make the same statistical mistake by cherry picking one season, and calling this a wrap. Let's go to the 2010 MLB season and do the same thing. The true final standings are right here, and here are the 16-game standings (Taken from April 23, 2010 unless otherwise noted):

American League

EAST
Tampa Bay (4/22) 12-4 .750
NY Yankees 11-5 .688
Toronto (4/22) 9-7 .563
Boston (4/22) 6-10 .375
Baltimore (4/22) 2-14 .125

CENTRAL
Minnesota (4/22) 11-5 .688
Detroit (4/22) 9-7 .529
Cleveland 7-9 .438
Kansas City 6-10 .375
Chicago Sox (4/22) 5-11 .313

WEST
Oakland (4/21) 9-7 .563
Seattle (4/22) 9-7 .563
LA Angels (4/21) 8-8 .500
Texas 7-9 .438
National League
EAST
Philadelphia 10-6 .625
Florida 9-7 .563
Washington (4/22) 8-8 .500
Atlanta 8-8 .500
NY Mets (4/22) 7-9 .438

CENTRAL
St. Louis 10-6 .625
Milwaukee 8-8 .500
Pittsburgh 7-9 .438
Chicago Cubs (4/22) 6-10 .438
Cincinnati (4/22) 7-9 .438
Houston 6-10 .375

WEST
San Diego 10-6 .625
San Francisco 9-7 .563
Colorado 8-8 .500
Arizona 7-9 .438
LA Dodgers 7-9 .438
There's not as much variance in the top teams here. The top four teams in the real schedule are Phildelphia, Tampa Bay, The Yankees, and Minnesota. The top four teams in the 16-game schedule are Tampa Bay, the Yankees, Minnesota and a logjam between three different teams, including Philadelphia.

The bottom teams in the real schedule are Pittsburgh, Seattle, Baltimore and Arizona. In the 16-game schedule, the bottom teams are Baltimore, the White Sox, Houston, and a tie with Kansas City and Boston.

The division champions are slightly different here. The real division champions in the AL were Tampa, Minnesota and Texas with the Yankees getting the wild card. The NL was represented by Philadelpha, San Francisco and Cincinnati, with Atlanta getting the wild card.

The 16-game schedule has a minimal effect on the AL, just changing out Texas for Oakland. Just like 2011, though, the effect is more pronounced in the NL. The NL would have been represented by Philly, St. Louis, San Diego, and the wild card going to either Florida or San Francisco.

So, what's the big deal? The results were mostly the same with just a few quirks. Doesn't sound like much, but what's the variance? Try 81.73 percentage points per team, which equates to one win again.

What about 2009? Here are the final standings, and here's the 16-game schedule.

American League

EAST
Toronto 11-5 .688
Boston 10-6 .625
NY Yankees 9-7 .563
Baltimore 8-8 .500
Tampa Bay 8-8 .500

CENTRAL
Kansas City 9-7 .563
Chicago Sox 8-8 .500
Detroit 8-8 .500
Minnesota 7-9 .438
Cleveland 6-10 .375

WEST
Seattle 10-6 .625
Texas 7-9 .438
LA Angels 6-10 .375
Oakland 6-10 .375
National League
EAST
Florida 11-5 .688
Atlanta 8-8 .500
Philadelphia 8-8 .500
NY Mets 7-9 .438
Washington 3-13 .188

CENTRAL
St. Louis 11-5 .688
Pittsburgh 9-7 .563
Cincinnati 9-7 .563
Chicago Cubs 8-8    .500
Milwaukee 7-9 .438
Houston 6-10 .375

WEST
LA Dodgers 11-5 .688
San Diego 10-6 .625
San Francisco 8-8 .467
Arizona 6-10 .375
Colorado 5-11 .313
What’s the variance? 98.53 percentage points. That’s a win, once again.

Let's try 2008. Here's the 16-game schedule, and compare this with the real standings.

American League

EAST
Boston 9-7 .563
Baltimore 9-7 .563
NY Yankees 9-7 .563
Toronto 8-8 .500
Tampa Bay 7-9 .438

CENTRAL
Chicago Sox 10-6 .625
Kansas City 9-7 .563
Minnesota 7-9 .438
Cleveland 6-10 .375
Detroit 5-11 .313

WEST
LA Angels 9-7 .563
Oakland 9-7 .563
Seattle 8-8 .500
Texas 7-9 .438
National League
EAST
NY Mets 10-6 .625
Florida 9-7 .563
Philadelphia 8-8 .500
Atlanta 7-9 .438
Washington 4-12 .250

CENTRAL
St. Louis 11-5 .688
Milwaukee 10-6 .625
Chicago Cubs 10-6 .625
Pittsburgh 7-9 .438
Cincinnati 7-9 .438
Houston 6-10 .375

WEST
Arizona 12-4 .750
San Diego 8-8 .500
Colorado 8-8 .467
LA Dodgers 7-9 .438
San Francisco 6-10 .375
The variance here is 83.9 percentage points. Again, a full win.

We'll stop here, because I think we get the point: Every year, because of football's short schedule, there's a possibility that a team either has one MORE or one LESS win than they deserve.

So why does all of this matter? Football isn't the same as baseball after all, and who cares if your team has one more win or one more loss?

Well, if you're having a historically great season, it might not matter. If your team goes 15-1 or 14-2, that doesn't change the fact that it was a great season. If your team is historically bad, it doesn't really matter. What's the difference between 4-12 or 3-13?

However, it does matter if you're a fan of any number of teams that go 7-9, 8-8, 9-7 or 10-6 during the season. A little bit of good luck, and your team is in the playoffs with a punter's chance at a Super Bowl. A little bit of bad luck and your team misses the playoffs and maybe your coach who really wasn't that bad gets fired.

Maybe your team is better than the record shows. Maybe they just need some time to gel and work together, but over the span of just 16 games, they don't have the opportunity.

"So are you suggesting that they lengthen the season?" Absolutely not. How can you, when you have athletes whose bodies are destroyed, like Jim McMahon:

McMahon now says his brain doesn’t work well.

“Short term memory is not good,” McMahon said. “I won’t remember a hell of a lot about this interview in 10 minutes.”
Take Kyle Turley, who said:
You start on your own five-yard line, and drive all the way down the field—fifteen, eighteen plays in a row sometimes. Every play: collision, collision, collision. By the time you get to the other end of the field, you're seeing spots. You feel like you are going to black out. Literally, these white explosions—boom, boom, boom—lights getting dimmer and brighter, dimmer and brighter.
What about poor Dave Duerson, who shot himself in the chest so he could have his brain examined? No, you can't lengthen the season. That's the nature of football.

Therein lies the problem. You can't get the good teams to shake out statistically when the way to do is to lengthen the season, which you can't do for player safety, and if the best teams aren't in the playoffs, then what's the point?

You may argue, “But the best team doesn’t win the Super Bowl every year! I mean, some of these years, the wild card team won, or the supposed ‘best’ team lost in the first round of the playoffs!” This is true, but once again, we’re dealing with a very small sample size. Even in baseball, during a seven-game series, almost every team has a chance versus any other team.

This study is not concerned with who wins in the playoffs, because that's prone to variance. When a team gets to the playoffs, anything can happen, and countless pro football teams haven't been able to get to the playoffs precisely because there's an underlying problem with the game itself that can't be fixed under any circumstances.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Prince Fielder to the Tigers

So Prince Fielder is a Tiger now. Surprising, but not completely out-of-left-field.

First, Detroit is pretty close to the Milwaukee area. By all accounts, Prince loves the Midwest, so that's a good fit. Second, the Tigers are a pretty decent team already. He's not going to have to sit through another long rebuilding process like he would in Toronto, Baltimore or other possible destinations. Third, he'll have plenty of protection in the lineup with Cabrera batting nearby him. If he's having an off day, he knows he's not the only one who has to score.

All in all, all of us Brewers knew Prince was leaving and hoped he wouldn't be going to an NL team, or even worse, the Cubs. This is about the best possible arrangement for everyone involved.

Good luck, Prince!

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Pujols to the Angels!

Wow! So the Cardinals have lost Albert Pujols to the Anaheim Angels!

So are they going to make an effort to sign Prince Fielder now? Who knows! I can't wait to see what happens!

I also can't stop using exclamation points!!!!!

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Two More Playoff Teams Added to Baseball... Too Many?

MLB has announced today that two more wild card playoff teams will be added starting in 2013 and quite possibly 2012. That brings the total amount up to 10 teams.

Is that too many teams? Baseball purists may seem to think so. After all, baseball has historically had very high standards for playoff teams. You usually had to win your division in order to be in the playoffs in years gone by. The wild card is a recent invention for the game, only showing up in 1994. Is it too soon to add another wrinkle? Are two more playoff teams two too many?
First, let's consider how many playoff teams get in to the playoffs in the other major sports.

In the NFL, with 32 teams, each division winner and two wild card teams per conference make it in, for a total of 12 teams. That's 37.5% of the total teams.

In the NBA, with 30 teams, eight teams per conference make it in, for a total of 16. That's 53.3%.

In the NHL, with 30 teams, eight teams from each conference end up in the playoffs. Once again, 53.3% of teams are in the playoffs.

With MLB's old rules, only four teams per league ended up in the playoffs. That's eight total out of 30 teams. That's 26.6% of the league.

If we add two more teams total, that brings our total of playoff teams to ten. That's 33.3% of the league will end up in the playoffs.

In comparison to the other major sports here in the US, baseball will still have some high standards for who gets to go to the playoffs, higher than all the other major sports.

Second, it won't hurt the sport that badly. We don't know how the rules will shake out, so we can't sort out what the matchups would have been exactly. Still, consider: This year, the Red Sox and the Braves, two very large markets, would have been in the playoffs. In 2010, the Red Sox and San Diego Padres would have been in. In 2009, the Detroit Tigers and the San Francisco Giants would have been in, and so on. These are all decent teams, honestly.

So it wouldn't kill baseball to add two more teams. It wouldn't water down competition, and it's still far better than most other major sports leagues.

Edit: Deadspin likes it as well:
We've known this was coming for a while, but it's worth emphasizing if only because it's so rare that baseball does something clever. The purists will complain about playoff creep, but in a single stroke, the league ensured that a larger share of teams have an incentive to compete until the end of the season (whether it's the division leaders who don't want to slip into the uncertainty of the one-game wild card playoff, or the middling teams for whom a handful of additional wins might mean a playoff run). That's good for fans, and that's good for baseball's revenue streams. It's rare that those two things line up.

Monday, October 31, 2011

Tony La Russa Retires

I hate the Cardinals. I hate Tony La Russa. I hate how all of his teams have sticks up their collective bottoms. I hate how they think that the "right way to play" means you can't have fun.

However, Tony La Russa invented the modern bullpen, and his success is undeniable. So, happy retirement, TLR. Now get out of the NL Central and don't let the door hit you on the way out.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

In Which I Pick A Hockey Team

It's time for me to pick a hockey team to follow.

I say this because usually I would start following basketball in passing around this time of year, even though I hate basketball. It just gives me someone to root for, while not necessarily caring about the sport. However, since the Bucks are frequently terrible with no hope to ever do anything worth paying attention to, it's time to focus my efforts elsewhere.

Plus, hockey has the best trophy in all of professional sports. The Lombardi Trophy is nice, but it doesn't come close to the Stanley Cup in terms of history. Hockey's also got the coolest game (pun not intended) in the Winter Classic and an awesomely rugged history.


I've always had a passing (hah!) interest in hockey, but it's difficult to follow here without any pro team in Wisconsin. Here's what baffles me:

Fact: Wisconsin is practically a solid sheet of ice for nine months out of the year.

Fact: The University of Wisconsin has one of the best hockey programs in the country.

Fact: People here actually like hockey.

Fact: There is no professional hockey team in Wisconsin (aside from the Milwaukee Admirals, who don't really count).

Fact: There are, however, hockey teams in Phoenix and San Jose, places where ice does not naturally exist unless it is in the form of a margarita, which naturally form in the Great Margarita Springs nearby Alamogordo, New Mexico. Alamogordo's slogan: "Our name means 'Fat Alamo!'"

So, yeah, Tampa Bay has a hockey team and they don't want it. Wisconsin has no hockey team and we could support it. Figure that out.

So I'd like to pick a hockey team to follow, but I have to set some ground rules first.
  1. No warm-weather teams. If there is no time during the year that you can play hockey outdoors in your city, then you shouldn't have a team. That leaves out Phoenix, Anaheim, Tampa, Carolina, Dallas, Los Angeles, San Jose, Nashville, and "Florida," wherever that is.
  2. Not the Blackhawks. I know it's the closest team to where I live, but I hate Chicago teams on principle. It's a Wisconsin thing.
  3. I'm not going to follow a team that's currently great. I don't want to be a frontrunner or bandwagon fan. Picking a team just because they're good isn't what being a fan is about. You have to suffer through some losses before you can really call yourself a fan. That leaves out Boston, Pittsburgh, Detroit and New Jersey (due to their run in the 90's).
With that in mind, here's what's left:

New York Islanders
New York Rangers
Philadelphia Flyers
Buffalo Sabres
Montreal Canadiens
Ottawa Senators
Toronto Maple Leafs
Washington Capitals
Winnipeg Jets
Columbus Blue Jackets
St. Louis Blues
Calgary Flames
Colorado Avalanche
Edmonton Oilers
Minnesota Wild
Vancouver Canucks

Let's narrow that down. First, I can't root for a New York team. As much as I like the city itself, rooting for a New York sports team when you don't live there is like rooting for the house at a casino. I don't want to root for the Capitals, since there's something about Ovechkin I don't like. I don't even know the guy and have never seen a picture of him, and yet he annoys me for some undetermined reason.

Ohio sucks, so no Blue Jackets. I don't like the St. Louis Cardinals, so I can't in good conscience root for the Blues. The Avalanche are out too because I hate the whole "Hey, our name is singular even though it should be plural" thing. That rules out the Minnesota Wild, too. Seriously, what is a "Wild?" Can an abstract concept even be a team name? I'm going to name any sports team I buy "The Existential Ennui." Make a logo for that.

That leaves us with:

Philadelphia Flyers
Buffalo Sabres
Montreal Canadiens
Ottawa Senators
Toronto Maple Leafs
Winnipeg Jets
Calgary Flames
Edmonton Oilers
Vancouver Canucks

Look at that, mostly Canadian teams. Since Wisconsin shares a border with Canada, we've always felt somewhat close to America's Hat. In many ways, due to our relative isolation, we share lots of similarities to Canada, like winter sports, lumberjacks, maple syrup and goofy accents.

Anyway, let's go further. We'll say no to the Flyers, because Philly fans suck. I'm cutting out the Canadiens and the Canucks because I'm not Canadian. It would be like a Canadian fan rooting for a team called "The Scooter-Riding Overeaters" or "The People Who Infest Walmart." It's same reason I'll eliminate the Leafs, besides its odd grammatical pluralization.

That leaves us with:

Buffalo Sabres
Ottawa Senators
Winnipeg Jets
Calgary Flames
Edmonton Oilers

All right, crunch time. We'll make some tough decisions here.

The Sabres have only been in the Finals twice, which certainly qualifies for the "don't pick a winner" stipulation. However, they've only been around since 1970. It would be like trying to pick a football team and ending up with the Seahawks. I'm looking for a little more tradition here. Sorry, Buffalo.

The Senators have an odd history. The original incarnation that lasted until the 30's had 11 Stanley Cup wins but folded due to financial problems. They were revived in the 1990's as an expansion team. We'll put a pin in this one, just because of the old-time history.

The Jets have a fractured history as well, but all of the team's history has stayed with the Phoenix Coyotes. It's kind of like the Frankenstein Cleveland Browns in the NFL, and I'm not sure I like that. Plus, their original incarnation (that recently moved from Atlanta) was only around starting in the 70's. I'll pass.

The Flames aren't consistent frontrunners. They've won only one Stanley Cup in their history. I even like the name "Calgary." However, the Oilers had Wayne Gretsky in the 80's. Dang. This is a tough call.

So we're down to three teams: The Senators, the Flames and the Oilers. I'm going to have to go with my gut on this one.

Calgary Flames? You have a new fan. Congratulations, I'm sure you're very proud.

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

So The Brewers Lost

It's taken me a day or two to digest the Brewers' loss in the NLCS, but here's what it comes down to: The problems are fixable.

First of all, if you would have told me at the beginning of the year that the Crew would win 96 games and the division and end up in the NLCS, I would have been happy with that.


That being said, there are a few gaping holes that the Cardinals exposed in the Brewers: 1) A weak bottom half of the lineup and 2) Poor defense. Things won't get any easier next year. They'll more than likely be without Prince Fielder, leaving a 300-pound hole in the top half of the lineup. They'll probably lose LaTroy Hawkins and K-Rod in free agency, which means they'll have to rebuild their bullpen.

That's a lot of holes to fill, but there is some good news in all of this. Scanning over the list of the free agent class of 2012, there are a few options. Here are some hypotheticals:

1) Keep everything in-house. Move McGeehee over to 1st base to minimize the impact of his defense. Re-sign Hairston for another year, then run Taylor Green out there starting in about May. Pick up Yuniesky Betancourt's option.

Advantage: Cheap and easy.

Disadvantage: You're not upgrading your defense up the middle. Rickie Weeks isn't a defensive mastermind, and Yuni's troubles are well-known. They were close to benching him before he started getting hits. Taylor Green, while a hot prospect, is an unknown commodity defensively.

2) Replace Yuni with someone else
. ANYONE else will do. His UZR rating is third from the bottom of every day shortstops on Fangraphs. His bat goes hot and cold, and since it was mostly hot this year it'll probably run cold next year. All told, he takes more runs off the board than he adds.

You can still shuffle the infield if you do this. Casey goes to first, Taylor Green to third, but then your unknown commodity goes to short. He wouldn't be relied upon to hit home runs, but rather just provide a solid defensive front up the middle.

I like this plan a lot. Consider your new batting lineup if you do this:
Hart
Morgan/Gomez
Braun
McGeehee
Weeks
Hairston/Green
Unknown Shortstop
Lucroy
Pitcher
"So why are you batting McGeehee fourth? He sucks!" Well, he won't have to concentrate so much on his defense, and his general slowness will fit in perfectly over at first. He'll also see more pitches with Braun in front of him and Weeks behind him, and a guy with a .250 batting average and big bat is about prototypical for a cleanup man. Plus, with this, I'm keeping Rickie in a position where he's comfortable and leaving the lineup mostly untouched.

Advantage: An instant bump to defense.

Disadvantage: Who exactly do the Brewers get? Nick Punto? The best defensive players are pretty well locked up, and they usually come with good bats to boot. One option might be Marco Scutaro of the Red Sox, but he was the one bright spot in their season and has a 2012 option. I doubt they'll want to let him go. Rafael Furcal is also on the table, but his defense isn't what it used to, and his bat was limp almost all year.

Plus, there are two players that are near the top of Fangraph's 2011 UZR rankings: J.J. Hardy and Alcides Escobar. That may show you the Brewers' commitment to defense right there.

----

So what will probably happen? Option Number One is more likely. From recent history, we can see that when Doug Melvin doesn't see a player he covets, he doesn't run out and get a random guy but instead stands pat with what he has. Unless he can get a substantial upgrade at a position that includes a bat and a glove, he's not likely to make the deal.

At this point I trust Doug Melvin, but if we're losing such a major part of the offense like Prince it's imperative that they make up for it. Since hitters who bat .300 and hit 35 HRs don't fall out of the sky every day, defense is the way to do it.

Big h/t to Cot's Baseball Contracts.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Gregg Easterbrook and "Glory Boys"

I've been reading Tuesday Morning Quarterback for years now, Gregg Easterbrook's weekly analysis of football and whatever else catches his fancy. Some people don't like him.

Drew Magary of Kissing Suzy Kolber and Deadspin can't stand him and eviscerates him to hilarious effect every week. Others are of the opinion that when he talks about science he doesn't always have all the facts or misrepresents them.
I'm not here to defend his science acumen. He's not a scientist, just a passive observer who sounds like he knows what he's talking about, even if he doesn't. I'm also not going to defend his reuse of certain cliches, because they can get annoying. When he sticks to football strategy, though, he's usually pretty solid, except for one major thing that bothers me.

One of Drew Magary's main complaints (aside from Easterbrook having far too many "g"s in his first name) is Easterbrook's glorification of "hard-working" players as opposed to "glory boys" who are generally drafted high. Easterbrook believes that if a team has lots of undrafted players, those teams generally play harder. Teams that have lots of highly-paid high draft picks don't. When a team bows to one player, whether that player is Michael Crabtree, T.O. or Chad Ochocinco, the whole team suffers.

For example, here's a quote from today's column:
In other football news, TMQ loves all-unwanted players -- those who were undrafted, or waived, or both. Sunday, the cost-no-object Philadelphia Heat, with their profusion of high draft choices and big bonuses, faced off against the low-rent Buffalo Bills. The host team started 12 players who were undrafted, or waived, or both. Undrafted George Wilson had 11 tackles and an interception: the Bills' defense appeared to be fielding several players wearing Wilson's number. When undrafted wide receiver Donald Jones left injured, undrafted wide receiver Naaman Roosevelt came in to relieve him and had five catches. The Bills start two offensive linemen who were undrafted or waived or both, and have allowed the fewest sacks in the league. The best player on the field for either team was undrafted Fred Jackson out of Division III Coe College, who gained 196 yards rushing and receiving.
The undrafted Jackson is just shy of a pace to break Chris Johnson's NFL record for yards from scrimmage. The undrafted Wes Welker of the New England Patriots is on a pace to break Jerry Rice's single-season receiving yards record. The undrafted Tony Romo of the Dallas Cowboys is on a pace to break Dan Marino's record for passing yards in a season. The defending champion Green Bay Packers start four undrafted players. On Sunday night, Julio Jones of the Atlanta Falcons -- one of the most expensive players in NFL annals, obtained by the Falcons for two first-round choices, a second-rounder and two fourth-round selections -- went deep and saw the pass broken up by the undrafted Sam Shields.

Across the league, undrafted players are outperforming megabucks high draft choices. Perhaps the undrafted players excel because they are undrafted -- spending their time and energy on performing, rather than on me-first whining.

In this case, Easterbrook is right and wrong. Yes, it certainly appears that teams with lots of highly-paid high draft picks don't play as hard, while undrafted and low-round players do. However, he's looking at the symptom and ignoring the cause.

If you have a lot of top-ten draft picks on your team, what is that a sign of? How do you get top-ten draft picks? By having a bad year. It's one thing for a team to have one bad season and get a high draft pick. It's another entirely for a team to have several bad seasons in a row, and that's when you see several top-ten draft picks on the roster.

Alex Smith: What might have been?
If a team has several bad seasons in a row, what does that mean? They're poorly run teams. Either ownership isn't very good, they have a bad general manager or poor coaching. Take a look at the Bengals, Dolphins, 49ers, Raiders, the Millen-run Lions, and others and you'll usually see some sort of chaotic situation. Either they're swapping out coaches like some players change their spikes or they're making bad personnel decisions.

Now, let's go another step. If you're a badly run team, you're more likely to make a poor choice with a high draft pick than a good choice, correct? You're more likely to spend a top-ten choice on a guy like JaMarcus Russell, and once you have that bad player you can't cover up his badness with good coaching, being as how there's too much organizational chaos for a coach to make his mark.

Plus, even if you select a good player, organizational dysfunction may stunt the player's growth. Worse yet, the player may be surrounded with 52 tackling dummies every game, making the good player look much worse and destroying his psyche.

Consider the case of Alex Smith and Aaron Rodgers. It's easy to say that Aaron Rodgers is the better quarterback now. He's a Super Bowl MVP, and a surefire MVP candidate this year. But what if the two players' situations were switched? What if Rodgers would have went 1st overall to the 49ers and Smith would have plummeted to 25th?

This could have actually happened. Rodgers was almost the first overall pick before the Niners talked themselves out of it. Remember, there was a major knock on Rodgers before the draft. He was a Jeff Tedford-coached quarterback from Cal. Tedford QBs (such as Trent Dilfer, Akili Smith, David Carr, Joey Harrington, and Kyle Boller) don't have a very high success rate in the NFL. Alex Smith had a major knock on him too: He came from a shotgun spread offense, so he wasn't used to taking snaps under center and reading defenses pre-snap.

So what if we switch places? Let's send Rodgers to San Francisco, where he has two different head coaches in his first three years and three different offensive coordinators, including Mike Martz. Then, let's put Alex Smith in Green Bay, where he sits on the bench, learns for three years behind Brett Favre in one of the most stable franchises in the NFL, and then finally gets his chance with a great supporting cast and a supportive fan environment.

Geez, they even kind of LOOK similar.
Now let's see who's more successful. Could Rodgers still have flourished in San Fran? Maybe. Would Alex Smith have flopped in Green Bay? Maybe. But you can't deny that the organizational stability and unique situations helped push it one way or the other.

Therefore, a team full of "highly paid glory boys" might not be a bad team because of said glory boys. They may be a bad team because they're poorly coached and trained on how to do their jobs. If you take a low draft pick or undrafted player and put them on the good team, they won't magically be any better than the high draft picks.

However, you could also make the argument that players change teams. A team with several first-round draft pick players and high bonuses may not necessarily be a team that earned those players through bad play, but rather paid for them through free agency.

That may be true, but let's look at that reasoning. Do players who were high draft picks generally change teams if they're really good players? No. Peyton Manning hasn't changed teams. Andre Johnson hasn't changed teams. Larry Fitzgerald hasn't changed teams. Mario Williams hasn't changed teams. Calvin Johnson hasn't changed teams. Joe Thomas hasn't changed teams.

What type of players switch teams? Players who were either drafted too high, like Ted Ginn Jr., or who weren't as good as advertised, like Reggie Bush. So essentially, a team that's stacked with first-round players is a team that's paying for players that aren't as good as that "first-round" designation would imply, and quite possibly overpaying to get them. Of course, overpaying for a bad player means that you have less money and resources to get a good player, and the cycle continues.

Now, in some cases, game-changing players like Nnamdi Asomugha do indeed change teams. But generally, these cases are the exception rather than the norm. They get so much ink precisely because it's very rare for an impact player to be on the market in general, and they usually don't end up on the market unless their skills are declining (Donovan McNabb) or there's some major personality issue (Randy Moss circa 2005).

Going back to the above examples of Ted Ginn and Reggie Bush, you'll notice something: Ginn was drafted by Miami and left. Bush was drafted by New Orleans and went to... Miami. Miami had a 1-15 season a few years ago and has hovered around incompetence for years, ever since Don Shula retired. Since then, the organization as a whole has been in flux.

That's what we're talking about: Teams that have lots of "glory boys" aren't losers on the basis of those players, but are losers because they're bad teams, which allows them to pick up the "glory boy" type of player. Since the team is bad, they'll either overreach to get a player that isn't that good, or they'll ruin that player's career through mismanagement.

What about undrafted players? Is it just that they work harder to earn their place on the team, as opposed to players who don't have to try?

Look, undrafted players are usually undrafted for a reason. There's usually a fundamental flaw in their game. Maybe they're too small. Maybe they didn't stack up against good competition so it's hard to say how good they actually are. Maybe they're not that strong, or have had injuries that raise major question marks.

So what kind of teams end up with really good undrafted players? This may come as a bit of a shock, but they're usually teams with good coaches. Take New England. They have Danny Woodhead, who's was undrafted because he's very undersized. He's not used very much (in fact, this year barely at all) but he plays hard. Since the Patriots have good coaching, they're able to hide this notable deficiency or minimize it, using him only situationally.

Take the Packers of last year. They ended up trotting out undrafted player after undrafted player and continued to win. Yet the players were picked by Ted Thompson, one of the most even-keeled (some would say comatose) GMs around. They were coached on offense by Mike McCarthy, who has proved his worth in that department, and on defense by Dom Capers, one of the best defensive coordinators ever.

Remember: There are a lot of players throughout the league who are low draft picks or undrafted players. Almost every player in the NFL is a professional who wants to play hard and realizes that working hard is the only way to stay on a roster. There are very few players who just decide to coast on "natural ability," and if they do, they're out of the league in a few short years. Everyone in the NFL has natural ability. If they didn't, they wouldn't have gotten this far.

A good team, however, will identify players that will be able to fill a role inside their system whether or not they were drafted. A team that succeeds with lots of undrafted players doesn't succeed because of them, but rather in spite of them. They succeed because they're a well-run organization with good coaching that knows how to hide their players' weaknesses and play to their strengths. They know how to balance the "highly paid glory boys" and the low-round-draft-pick players.

So "glory boys" aren't the death of teams. Undrafted or "unwanted" players aren't their salvation. A lot of high draft picks are the sign of a poorly-run team, not the other way around. A lot of "unwanted" players who succeed are the sign of a well-run team and nothing more.

Friday, October 7, 2011

Friday, September 30, 2011

Terry Francona Out As Manager of the Red Sox

After the Red Sox epic collapse, there was a lot of blame to go around. The hitter went ice-cold, the pitchers couldn't hit the strike zone with a bulldozer, there were no good arms available to pitch after injuries struck, and there were some weird managerial decisions made.

Which problem was the biggest cause? Hard to say, but probably the lack of pitching. Whose fault is that? The management, right? That's on Theo Epstein's doorstep. A few arms went down, they overspent on John Lackey and ended up with crap in the rotation.

So who takes the fall? Terry Francona. Explain to me how this works: How a manager can be a god early in the season, all of his players like him and the rotation is awful because the GM hasn't picked any good players, and yet the manager takes the hit.

This is why I prefer the management structure with teams like the Pittsburgh Steelers. They've had three coaches in 40 years: Chuck Noll, Bill Cowher and Mike Tomlin. If a coach has a bad year, you evaluate whether he had a bad year because of bad luck or bad coaching and go accordingly.

In this case, the Sox had a bad year because of bad GM-ing. Let's fire the manager instead! So much easier.

Ironclad Brewers Playoff Predictions

With the Brewers starting the playoffs tomorrow, I figured I would break down how each game is going to go. These are ironclad predictions, so you may not even need to watch the games.

Game 1: Yovani Gallardo pitches 9 innings and throws 27 strikeouts. Ryan Braun hits like 5 home runs and all of the Diamondbacks start crying in the dugout. Kirk Gibson breaks his leg during a particularly strong sob.

Game 2: Zack Greinke pitches 8 innings only because he got bored and sent out a pitching machine in an attempt to make the game even. The pitching machine gets 2 strikeouts and induces a groundout to end the game. Prince Fielder pulls down his pants and poops on Daniel Hudson at midfield after hitting his fourth home run as Hudson curls into the fetal position.

Game 3: The Brewers get to the Arizona stadium only to find that the Diamondbacks are still in their hotel rooms in Milwaukee, rending their garments and throwing ashes in the air. The Brewers decide to give the Diamondbacks some time to get to the stadium, so they postpone Game 3.

Game 3 (Redux): The Diamondbacks walk in to the stadium dragging their bats behind them, each with the expression of a man being led to the gallows. Each player has changed their walkup music to "Leaving on a Jet Plane."

The game begins with Stephen Drew lacing a hit to the outfield. That is the last hit they will get. By the sixth inning they're not even bringing a bat up to the plate, just weakly swinging at each pitch with their hand. After each at-bat, Jonathan Lucroy licks each batter's faces and says, "Your tears are like sweet wine to me."

The Brewers advance to the NLDS, leaving the Diamondbacks questioning the existence of God.

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Casey McGeehee! Where Have You Been?

Three homers in one day! Geez, who woke him up? Glad to have him back, and I hope he keeps it up.

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Why We Hate LeBron James Now

I found this article the other day. It basically says that people who hate on LeBron James are hypocrites and don't have any solid reason to hate him aside from jealousy.


In the author's opinion, we hate on LBJ because we don't like that he went to a different team and wants to win, or some twisted reason like that. He also believes that the more we hate him, the more we eat out of his hand, or something like that. He compares LBJ to Mahmoud Abdul-Rauf, who was villified for not standing during the national anthem, and says that LeBron owns the people who hate him.

The author doesn't understand why people hate LeBron James. It's not because he left the Cavs. If LeBron would have left and gone to Denver, the Clippers, the Knicks, or any other team, Cleveland residents would be the only people still complaining. When the Cavaliers dropped from 61 wins in 2009 to 19 in 2010, it became pretty obvious that LeBron was the only player that the Cavaliers had, so who can blame someone for getting out of a bad situation?

Even if he would have gone to a team that had a solid No. 2 guy but no No. 1, that would have been OK. What bothers us isn't that LeBron left Cleveland. What bothers us is that he got together with his buddies for the express purpose of winning a championship. To the people sitting at home, that smacks of laziness.

We respect athletes who work hard. Larry Bird, Michael Jordan, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Albert Pujols, that kind. We hear stories about them being the first to practice and the last to leave. We like that. We expect our athletes to leave it all on the floor for us because that's why we pay them so much money. That's the tradeoff: We pay you money, you entertain us by giving it your all every day.

That's why, for example, Michael Jordan was beloved. He never took nights off. He never just said, "Screw it," and drop a pass to someone else instead of taking it himself. He never took the easy way. He pushed himself and his teammates to work, work, work, sometimes to their detriment. That what it takes to get six championships.

This isn't a question of whether or not LBJ or D-Wade or Bosh work hard on the court. No one is denying that they play hard. What puts them behind the 8-ball is that they gave up. Instead of using that competitor's fire to make their own teams better, they grouped together for the express purpose winning championships every year. Compare this to the Dallas Mavericks, which is comprised of Dirk Nowitzki, the husk of Jason Kidd, the occasional Jason Terry sighting, and that's it. Dirk could win almost on his own. Why can't these guys?

The author of the article also hints at racism, and reading the previous paragraph, you might be tempted to think that we liked the Mavs this year because Dirk is white, and we hated the Heat's Big Three because they're all black. That's too easy of an explanation, though. Here's why. Consider other African-American athletes:

Kobe Bryant. I was always a Kobe-hater, but I'm changing my tune. Consider: He has Andrew Bynum, Lamar Odom and Ron Artest on his team. They're all No. 2 type of guys. You would never ask any of them to carry a team on their own, because they can't. Yet, Kobe won a title with these guys.

Tim Duncan. He has Tony Parker and Manu Ginobli. Neither of them are No. 1s. Yet, he won tons of championships with them. He's beloved in San Antonio and respected throughout the league.

Shaq. Shaq paired up with Kobe in LA, true. Yet, Kobe wasn't yet KOBE. He was merely a very talented player who wasn't still a little wet behind the ears. He needed time and maturity to carry a team. Once he got a little more mature, Shaq left. He needed to be the No. 1. He went to the Heat. Wade was still a No. 2 and only grew into the No. 1 role after Shaq left.

Kevin Garnett. Garnett grouped with Pierce and Ray Allen. Now, can Ray Allen carry a team on his own? When he was younger with the Bucks and Sonics, he kind of did, but he was viewed as a No. 2 before Garnett arrived. Pierce was also a guy who was on the cusp of being a No. 1 but couldn't quite get there.

See? It's not a race thing. No one was necessarily mad at any of these guys for being on the teams they were with except for those who hate on everything. KG even engineered his escape from Minnesota to end up on a contender, and when he won a championship we were HAPPY for him. It's not about race or trying to find the right team for yourself. It's about respect for the game and the fans.

For example, most people dislike the Yankees or Red Sox because they stack their teams with the most expensive and talented players and expect championships. When the Yankees won in the 90's, it was with guys like Paul O'Neill and Bernie Williams, along with Hall-Of-Famers like Jeter and Pettitte. These were guys who came up in the system together and became a TEAM together. Now that they stack their teams, we take a perverse pleasure in watching them lose.

We weren't mad that LeBron picked a different team, we were mad that he picked THIS SPECIFIC team with THESE SPECIFIC players. He went out and grouped himself with players that would get him an easy championship. He could fade down the stretch like he did last year and no one would notice because Wade and Bosh could pick up the slack. That's not respectful to the greats who came before, guys like Russell, Bradley and Mikan.

"But, what about letting him do what he wants to do? He's a human being! Maybe he doesn't want to follow the script we've set for him! Ever think about that, you heartless, selfish bastards?"

Here's the problem with that line of reasoning. We'll use a comparison between being an athlete and being a politician. They're very similar. Case in point: Who elects officials? We do. When we elect them, we expect them to represent us because we put them there. We pay their salaries, and when we stop liking them, we remove them.

OK, so who pays athletes? Well, same thing. We do. We pay with our tickets and watching them on TV. Therefore, we expect them to represent us because we put them there. If our team doesn't have athletes we like, we don't pay with our tickets or by watching them on TV. If we like an athlete, we pay them exorbitant amounts of money for our entertainment pleasure.

There's a reason that LeBron James gets paid more than, say, DeGasana Diop. It's because we, as the fans, want to see LeBron James more than Diop. We know he can do incredible things, so the payment is basically saying, "Hey, here's an advance on all the incredible stuff we expect you to do and payment for all the cool stuff you've already done. Good luck!"

That's why the argument of "Let the athlete do what he wants, it's his life" doesn't work. He gave up that right when we started giving him money to do awesome things for us. That's why we got mad at Ricky Williams when he walked away from football to hang out with gurus and get high: We paid him lots of money to entertain us, so we expect that he will do so.

Like, with LeBron, we paid him a lot of money to do incredible things on a basketball court. We paid him because sometimes we like to see an athlete transcend his sport and do something we've never seen. Instead, he took our money and did what he wanted to do instead of what we expected. Well, guess what? It doesn't work like that.

When a CEO takes enormous amounts of money for their work and don't accomplish anything, what do the stockholders do? They vote him out. When a politician takes more money than he deserves, what do they do? They kick him out. When someone gets more than they deserve, we get angry.

LeBron is blessed with a freakish amount of talent. It's fair to say that no other basketball player (and I'm including Jordan here) has as much as raw talent as LeBron has. He wanted to play basketball and use that talent to entertain us. When a person has that much talent and they decide to take it easy, we get angry. When we see someone like LBJ decide that he would rather hide his talent by letting someone else do the heavy lifting or treat his gift like something that is of no consequence, we get angry, and with good reason.

We get angry because we will never have that much talent, but we all want it. If we could have the talent that LeBron James has for one day, we would never, ever forget that day. We would dream about it. We would remember the one time we blew past three guys and dunked in the face of a fourth, ran down the court, blocked a shot, then took the ball the other way and drained a three with a defender's hand in our face. We would die with a smile on our face, remembering that one time.

Therefore, what we want to see, and what we pay LeBron to do, is use his talent to make his team better. If there was any doubt about that, all you have to do is look at how much hate is directed his way. The people who pay his salary have spoken.